Forbes thinks vertical farming is a “crackpot idea”

Newark Subsidizes A Crackpot Idea: Vertical Farming

Counterpoint to the article I posted yesterday on the vertical farm coming to Newark. Given the relative newness of the field, I’m not sure such negativity from Forbes is warranted.

It’s possible that because this is such a young industry that opportunities to scale haven’t been fully explored. And Beyer dismisses transportation costs with hand-waving—a not insubstantial cost of farming, especially if you’re bullish on oil prices increasing over the next few years.

But the economics seem unworkable. Businesses or governments wishing to run vertical farms would first have to buy land in major cities, where real estate is sold at premiums. They would spend millions on the approval costs required for development. They would throw enormous sums—nowadays in the billions—to construct mega-towers. And then they would have to further address the challenge of growing food indoors, which requires sophisticated lighting, irrigation, and retention systems.

It would be difficult for vertical farmers to cover all these costs by selling a bunch of $2 cucumbers, especially when competing with traditional (or “horizontal”) farmers. There is a reason, after all, that farming occurs in rural areas: land there is abundant and cheap.

Author: Ken Walker

Husband, Father, Analyst. In a glass case of emotion since 1978.

3 thoughts on “Forbes thinks vertical farming is a “crackpot idea””

  1. True and fact. Vertical farm is not economically feasible in terms of long term goal and hardly can not surpass with traditional farming system.


    1. Hi… I see your name as a desogner for this industry. Is that why you say vertical farming is not feasible? Whbesides LED power… What are some major roadblocks that you see? Thanks.


  2. That’s because Forbes isn’t thinking out of the box. Demand for the artisan farmer is growing. People in vertical farming need to quit thinking skyscrapers and start thinking owner-operator strip centers and business parks.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: